Construction, Planning
Practical Completion: Why handover doesn’t mean the contractor’s obligations are over
- Written by: Samuel Okoronkwo
- Published on:
Share
A building being ready for occupation does not mean the contractor has finished the job.
Yet the commercial pressure to achieve handover sometimes encourages project teams to treat practical completion as confirmation that the difficult work is behind them.
That assumption deserves challenging, particularly when significant defects or contractual obligations remain unresolved.
For developers, practical completion often means tenants are preparing to move in, and the development is approaching the point where it begins generating a return.
For contractors, it represents the end of a significant phase of delivery.
But practical completion also changes the contractual and commercial position of both parties.
The decision to certify it deserves greater scrutiny than simply establishing whether a building is ready for use.
What does practical completion establish?
Under many JCT contracts, practical completion has important consequences, including the start of the rectification period and the end of liability for liquidated damages for delayed completion, subject to the contract’s terms.
But the threshold for certification is not always straightforward.
In Mears Ltd v Costplan Services (South East) Ltd [2019] EWCA Civ 502, the Court of Appeal examined whether defects prevented practical completion.
The Court confirmed that practical completion is a matter of fact and degree. Minor defects may be consistent with practical completion, while more substantial defects can prevent certification.
Importantly, the ability to occupy a building does not automatically establish practical completion.
Commercial pressure should not determine certification
Anyone involved in development understands the pressures surrounding completion.
Developers have funding commitments and tenants expecting access. Contractors want to finish delivery and release resources for other projects.
Those pressures are legitimate, but they should not determine whether practical completion is certified.
Consider a development where the principal construction works are finished, but important elements remain incomplete.
The commercial team might argue that outstanding matters can be addressed after occupation.
The relevant question is whether those matters are sufficiently minor to permit certification under the contract.
Where they are not, issuing the certificate simply to achieve handover risks creating further contractual difficulties.
Professional judgement should determine certification, not the financial consequences of delaying it.
Certification changes the commercial position
One issue I believe deserves greater attention is how certification changes the parties’ respective commercial positions.
Depending on the contract, practical completion may trigger the release of part of the retention and bring the period for calculating liquidated damages for delayed completion to an end.
The contractor remains responsible for continuing contractual obligations, but the employer’s position changes.
Consider substantial remedial work becoming necessary after occupation.
The employer must coordinate access around tenants and building operations, while the contractor must return to address defects alongside other project commitments.
Disagreements might arise over whether particular works constitute defects or additional work.
Although contractual remedies remain available, securing remedial works becomes more complicated once the building is occupied.
This is why outstanding items and arrangements for remedial access should be established before handover.
Practical completion requires independent judgement
Having worked across quantity surveying, project management and construction law, I believe practical completion deserves the same disciplined attention as other significant contractual decisions.
Developers need confidence that the works satisfy the contractual requirements. Contractors need clarity about their continuing obligations.
My position is straightforward.
Practical completion should never be certified simply to satisfy a funding deadline or meet an anticipated occupation date.
Where contractual requirements have not been met, commercial inconvenience does not justify certification.
Should certifiers be more willing to resist commercial pressure at handover, even when withholding practical completion creates serious financial consequences?
contact us
Contact Samuel Okoronkwo
Get in touch today to speak directly with Samuel Okoronkwo for expert legal advice and assistance.
Blog
Related Articles
- Construction, Dispute Resolution, Planning
- Construction, Dispute Resolution, Planning